Amish Macaroni Salad

Sharing is caring!

Amish macaroni salad is the kind of side dish that always finds a way onto the plate. Even when the table is crowded with options. Even when you tell yourself you’re just grabbing a small spoonful. It’s creamy, slightly sweet, a little tangy, and packed with that familiar crunch from celery and onion. Simple food. But it hits.

This is the macaroni salad I reach for when I want something that tastes like it’s been made a hundred times, in the best way. The dressing is what sets it apart. Not overly sharp. Not cloying. It’s smooth and rich, with just enough vinegar to wake it up and just enough sugar to round out the edges. And once the pasta has time to soak up that flavor in the fridge, it turns into the kind of salad people “accidentally” keep scooping.

It also plays nice with whatever you’re serving. Grilled chicken. Burgers. Pulled pork. Fried fish. A simple sandwich. It doesn’t compete. It supports. And it holds its own while doing it.

This recipe is built for real life. It uses easy-to-find ingredients, it’s forgiving if you need to swap a veggie, and it gets better after a few hours in the fridge. Make it for a cookout. Make it for meal prep lunches. Make it for a Sunday fridge clean-out and enjoy it all week.

Ingredients

Here I explain the best ingredients for this Amish macaroni salad recipe, what each one does, and substitution options. For the exact ingredient measurements, jump to the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

Elbow macaroni

Classic elbows are the move here. They hold dressing inside the curve and stay easy to scoop.

A quick note on texture: macaroni salad tastes best when the pasta is cooked just past al dente. Not mushy. Just a touch softer than you’d serve hot. Cold pasta firms up in the fridge, so this keeps it from turning too chewy.

Mayonnaise

Mayo is the creamy base, and it matters. A good mayonnaise gives the salad richness and that smooth, cohesive feel.

If you’re used to macaroni salad that looks dry and broken, it’s usually because there’s not enough fat in the dressing or the pasta wasn’t cooled correctly. Mayo fixes the first part.

Yellow mustard

This gives the dressing that classic macaroni salad bite and a subtle sunny color. Dijon can work, but yellow mustard is the familiar flavor that fits Amish-style macaroni salad best.

Apple cider vinegar

Vinegar keeps the dressing bright so it doesn’t taste heavy. Apple cider vinegar is slightly mellow with a hint of sweetness.

White vinegar works too. It’s sharper, so start with a little less and taste as you go.

Sugar

This is what makes it “Amish style” for a lot of people. The dressing leans a little sweet, balanced by vinegar and mustard. It doesn’t taste like dessert. It tastes rounded and comforting.

Celery

Celery adds crunch and freshness. Dice it small so it spreads through the salad instead of dominating bites.

Onion

Onion adds savory bite. Use a sweet onion if you want a gentler flavor, or red onion if you like a little more edge.

If you’re serving a crowd that’s sensitive to raw onion, soak the diced onion in cold water for 10 minutes, then drain well. It softens the sharpness without removing the flavor.

Sweet pickle relish

Relish adds sweetness, tang, and texture all in one spoonful. It’s a small ingredient that does a lot.

If you don’t have relish, finely chop sweet pickles and use a splash of the pickle juice.

Hard-boiled eggs

Eggs add richness and a soft texture that makes the salad feel more filling. Totally classic in this style of macaroni salad.

If you’re not an egg person, you can leave them out. The salad still works.

Red bell pepper

This adds color and a light sweetness, plus a crisp bite that stays nice even after chilling.

Green bell pepper is also traditional, but red is a little sweeter and softer in flavor.

Salt and black pepper

Pasta salad needs enough seasoning to taste lively when it’s cold. Salt especially matters here because cold foods dull flavor.

Celery seed and paprika

Both optional, both good.

• Celery seed adds that old-school deli salad vibe in a subtle way.

• Paprika is great sprinkled on top for color and a mild warmth.

---

Ingredient notes and smart swaps

This recipe is flexible, and that’s one reason it’s such a good “go-to” side dish.

Mayo alternatives

If you want to lighten the salad a bit, you can replace some of the mayo with Greek yogurt or sour cream.

A good starting point is:

• ¾ mayo + ¼ plain Greek yogurt

This keeps the salad creamy and still tastes like macaroni salad, not like a yogurt bowl.

If you go all yogurt, the salad will be tangier and less rich. Still tasty, just different.

Vinegar options

• Apple cider vinegar: mellow and balanced

• White vinegar: sharper, more punch

• Lemon juice: brighter, slightly softer than vinegar

If you use white vinegar, reduce it slightly at first. You can always add more.

Relish options

• Sweet pickle relish: classic

• Dill relish: less sweet, more tang

• Chopped bread-and-butter pickles: sweet and tangy, great texture

If you go with dill, bump the sugar slightly to keep the Amish-style sweetness.

Veggie swaps

You can add or swap vegetables based on what you have:

• shredded carrot for sweetness and color

• chopped cucumber for extra crunch (seed it and pat dry)

• green onions for a softer onion bite

Just keep everything diced small so the salad stays scoopable and balanced.

---

What makes it “Amish style”

Amish macaroni salad usually has a few things going on at once:

• A creamy mayonnaise base

• Mustard for bite

• Vinegar for brightness

• A noticeable, but not overwhelming, sweetness

• Crunch from celery and onion

• Often eggs and sweet pickle relish

It’s not meant to be sharp like a vinaigrette pasta salad. It’s meant to be comforting. Gentle. The kind of side dish you can eat with anything and still want another spoonful.

And the chilling time matters. A lot. This salad is good right away, but after a few hours in the fridge, the macaroni absorbs the dressing and the flavors settle into each other. That’s when it tastes like the real deal.

---

How to make Amish macaroni salad

I’ve included step-by-step instructions below to make this recipe easy to follow at home. For the full detailed recipe instructions and ingredient quantities, scroll to the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

1) Cook the macaroni

Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil.

Add the elbow macaroni and cook it just past al dente, usually 1–2 minutes longer than the box suggests for hot pasta. You want it tender, but still holding its shape.

Drain the pasta immediately.

2) Cool the pasta the right way

Rinse the macaroni under cold water until it’s cool to the touch. Drain well.

Then let it sit in the colander for a few minutes to shake off extra water. Water hiding in the pasta turns the dressing runny later, so draining matters.

3) Prep the add-ins

While the pasta drains, get everything ready:

• dice celery

• dice onion

• dice bell pepper

• chop eggs

• measure relish

Keeping the dice small makes the salad easier to eat and gives you better flavor in every bite.

4) Make the dressing

In a bowl, whisk together:

• mayonnaise

• yellow mustard

• apple cider vinegar

• sugar

• salt and pepper

• celery seed (optional)

Taste the dressing. It should taste slightly bold and a touch sweet. Once it’s mixed with pasta and chilled, it mellows.

5) Combine and chill

In a large bowl, combine the cooled macaroni with celery, onion, bell pepper, relish, and eggs.

Pour the dressing over and stir gently until everything is coated.

Cover and refrigerate for at least 2 hours. Overnight is even better if you’re prepping for an event.

Before serving, stir again and taste. Add a pinch more salt if needed. Cold pasta loves salt.

Sprinkle paprika on top if you like that classic finish.

---

Two dressing options

Some people want the simplest method. Some people love the old-fashioned cooked dressing that thickens slightly and clings to pasta like a dream.

Both work. Here’s how to choose.

Option 1: Quick mix dressing

This is the recipe card version. You whisk the dressing and mix it in. Fast, reliable, still tastes classic.

Best when:

• you want it done in under 30 minutes

• you don’t want extra steps

• you’re making it for a weeknight side

Option 2: Cooked Amish-style dressing

This version makes the salad feel extra old-school. It’s a little thicker, a little silkier, and it holds up beautifully in the fridge.

To make it:

1. In a small saucepan, whisk together

   • ¾ cup sugar

   • ¾ cup apple cider vinegar

   • 1 tablespoon yellow mustard

   • 1 tablespoon all-purpose flour

   • ½ cup water

2. Cook over medium heat, whisking constantly, until it thickens, about 4–6 minutes.

3. Remove from heat and cool completely.

4. Whisk the cooled mixture into the mayonnaise, then proceed as usual.

This gives you that slightly custardy dressing feel, without making the salad heavy.

If you use the cooked dressing, you can reduce the mayo slightly since the dressing has more body.

---

Recipe tips

These tips keep the salad creamy, flavorful, and the right texture for days.

Salt the pasta water

Macaroni salad can taste bland if the pasta itself is unseasoned. Salted water fixes that from the start.

Drain the pasta well

Rinsing cools the pasta and stops cooking, but leftover water is the enemy. Give the colander time. Shake it. Let it drip. It matters.

Chop everything small

Big chunks of onion or celery can take over bites. Small dice makes it feel balanced and easy to scoop.

Chill before serving

The salad needs chill time. Two hours gives the pasta time to absorb flavor and the dressing time to thicken slightly.

If you serve it right away, it can taste a little sharp and the dressing can feel thinner. After chilling, it tastes blended and settled.

Adjust seasoning at the end

Cold food dulls flavor, so always taste after chilling. Often it needs:

• a pinch more salt

• a crack of pepper

• a tiny splash of vinegar if you want more brightness

---

Variations and add-ins

This salad is classic, but you can tweak it without losing the Amish-style vibe.

Add shredded cheese

A handful of mild cheddar or Colby adds richness and makes it feel more filling. Keep it light so it doesn’t overpower the dressing.

Add cooked bacon

Crisp bacon adds smoky, salty contrast against the sweet dressing. Sprinkle it in right before serving so it stays crisp.

Make it extra crunchy

Add:

• extra celery

• diced cucumber (seeded and patted dry)

• chopped radish for a peppery bite

Make it less sweet

Reduce the sugar slightly and add a little more vinegar. The salad will taste sharper and more traditional deli-style.

A good adjustment is cutting the sugar by 1–2 tablespoons. Keep the rest the same.

Make it more sweet-tang

Increase relish slightly and add a splash of pickle juice. That gives you more punch without needing more sugar.

Add herbs

Fresh parsley or dill can be lovely, especially in warmer weather. Just keep it subtle so the salad still tastes classic.

---

What to serve it with

Amish macaroni salad fits anywhere a creamy side dish belongs.

Try it with:

• grilled burgers and hot dogs

• pulled pork sandwiches

• BBQ chicken or smoked chicken

• fried chicken

• deli-style sandwiches

• baked beans and corn on the cob

• crispy chicken tenders for a casual dinner plate

It’s also a strong picnic option because it’s satisfying without needing to be piping hot. Just keep it cold and covered.

---

Make-ahead, storage, and leftovers

This is a make-ahead side dish at heart.

Make ahead

Make it the day before and let it sit overnight. The flavor gets better, the dressing thickens slightly, and the texture turns perfect.

If you’re worried about crunch, you can hold back a small handful of celery and stir it in right before serving.

Storage

Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days.

Stir before serving each time. Pasta absorbs dressing as it sits, so the salad may look a bit thicker the next day.

If it looks dry, stir in 1–2 tablespoons mayo to loosen it back up. A tiny splash of vinegar can also bring back brightness.

Food safety notes

Keep the salad refrigerated. If it’s sitting out at a cookout, set the bowl over a larger bowl of ice and keep it covered between servings.

Freezing

I don’t recommend freezing macaroni salad. Mayo-based dressings separate after thawing, and the pasta texture turns soft in an unpleasant way.

---

Troubleshooting

Even simple pasta salad can go sideways. Here’s how to fix the common issues.

Salad tastes bland

This is usually salt.

Cold pasta needs enough seasoning to taste lively. Add a pinch of salt, stir, taste again. Repeat until it tastes right.

A little extra mustard can also help if it feels flat.

Salad is too sweet

Add a small splash of vinegar and a pinch of salt. Stir and taste. The vinegar cuts sweetness and makes the dressing feel sharper.

Salad is too tangy

Add 1–2 teaspoons sugar and 1 tablespoon mayo. Stir and taste. A little extra mayo softens sharpness quickly.

Dressing looks watery

This often happens when the pasta wasn’t drained well or veggies were wet.

Fix it by stirring in a little more mayo. If you have time, chill it for an hour. Cold helps the dressing tighten.

For next time, drain pasta longer and pat vegetables dry if they seem wet.

Pasta feels too firm after chilling

The pasta may have been cooked too al dente. Next time, cook it a minute longer.

For the current batch, let the salad sit at room temperature for 10 minutes before serving. It softens slightly and tastes creamier.

 

Sharing is caring!